
If you want to shop small in Northern Colorado this holiday season, you’re in the right place. Small Business Saturday is Nov. 28, and it’s one of our favorite days of the year. Downtown is busy, the windows are decorated, and every dollar you spend stays a little closer to home.
So we asked our team a simple question: where do you actually shop when you’re buying gifts? This guide is the answer. It covers Loveland, Fort Collins, Windsor, Timnath, Greeley, Berthoud, and a few spots worth the drive.
Local shops are a big part of what makes our towns feel like home. They sponsor the school fundraisers, fill the downtown storefronts, and know their regulars by name. Plus, you’ll find gifts you won’t see in every big-box store.
We marked a few of our team’s absolute favorites with a ♥ below. Start there if you’re short on time.

Downtown Loveland is easy to explore on foot, especially along 4th Street.
♥ Localist Localist is full of goods from local makers. It’s a great one-stop shop when you want a gift that feels like Northern Colorado.
Little Piece of My Heart Think candles, crystals, and feel-good finds with a little hippie spirit. The shop recently moved to West 4th Street, so look for its new spot.
Cloz to Home This downtown boutique carries cozy sweaters, jewelry, home décor, and easy gifts. It’s a good stop for anyone who’s hard to shop for.
The Stinging Nettle The Stinging Nettle is an herbal apothecary on 4th Street. You’ll find natural skincare, herbal teas, and plant-based wellness goods. It’s a thoughtful pick for the friend who loves self-care.
Tarnish Boutique Tarnish carries jewelry, accessories, and fashion pieces with a little personality. It’s perfect for stocking stuffers and small splurges.
Old Town Fort Collins could fill a whole afternoon of shopping. Here’s where we’d start.
♥ Curiosities Curiosities is packed with quirky, fun gifts. In fact, it’s our go-to for stocking stuffers.
Old Firehouse Books This beloved independent bookstore has books, journals, and gifts for the readers on your list. Ask the staff for a recommendation. They’re great at it.
Old Town Spice Shop Home cooks and grill lovers will be happy here. The shop sells spice blends, salts, and ready-made gift boxes.
Magpies Magpies is a locally owned shop with jewelry, décor, and gifts. You can easily cross a few names off your list in one stop.
Downtown Windsor’s Main Street has a small-town feel and some very sweet stops.
♥ Mr. Yo’s A gift card for Mr. Yo’s means a box of the kind of donuts you dream about. It’s hard to find a better gift.
High Desert Chocolates This Main Street shop makes handcrafted chocolates and specialty coffee. It also offers caramel apples and ice cream, so plan to treat yourself while you’re there.
Timnath’s small Main Street is worth a slow stroll.
Fine & Funky Fine & Funky is a boutique with clothing, jewelry, and accessories. It also carries kids’ gifts and Jellycat plush toys, which makes it a great stop for families.
Publick Market Coffee House Grab a coffee and browse the gift shop, which features goods from local artisans.
Downtown Greeley has a creative, independent shopping scene.
Warm Hugs Mixes & Gifts This shop sells homemade soup, dip, and baking mixes, plus handcrafted gifts and local art. It’s perfect for teachers, neighbors, and hosts.
Madison & Main Gallery Madison & Main is an artist co-op with paintings, pottery, jewelry, and woodwork. Every piece is made by a local artist.
Midnight Oil Midnight Oil is an independent bookstore with bestsellers and rare finds. It’s a great place to browse on a cold afternoon.
Berthoud’s Mountain Avenue is small-town Colorado at its best.
♥ Wishful Living Wishful Living offers thoughtful home décor and unique finds from around the world. It’s one of our favorite places to find something unexpected.
Berthoud Drug This hometown pharmacy has a gift shop up front. Stop in for candles, home décor, and small gifts.
These two shops are a little off the beaten path. However, they’re worth the trip.
Masonville Mercantile (Masonville) This spot has cozy vibes and an eclectic mix of clothing, books, local history, and more. Pair it with a scenic drive up Buckhorn Road.
Low Rider (Hygiene) Low Rider is a boutique with clothing, jewelry, and home goods. It’s a fun stop on a weekend drive toward Lyons.
Can’t decide? Several downtowns offer community gift cards that work at dozens of local businesses. For example, the Loveland Downtown District gift card works at more than 50 local spots. It’s an easy way to let someone pick their own favorite.
When you shop small in Northern Colorado, you help keep our downtowns lively and our neighbors in business. Also, you’ll probably find a better gift.
Did we miss your favorite local shop? Send us a note and tell us about it. We’d love to add it to next year’s list.
And if you’re looking for more ways to enjoy the season, grab our free Northern Colorado Fall Journal. It’s full of local favorites, from coffee shops to cozy dinner spots.

Save this guide on Pinterest for next year’s holiday shopping!
Offering personalized real estate services in Northern Colorado.
Based in Loveland, Colorado
Privacy Policy
Site Credit
Copyright 2026 haug & co.
Personalized real estate service based in Loveland, Colorado—helping buyers and sellers across Northern Colorado, including Fort Collins, Windsor, Greeley, Berthoud, and surrounding areas, move forward with calm confidence at every step.
CONTACT
HOME
BUYING
SELLING
Explore NoCO
SERVICES
ABOUT
BLOG